Car Clashes is my definition of "comparison". By putting two or more cars against each other, I will have an opportunity to bring their ins and outs to the light and consequently select a winner. To properly open this first edition, I shall compare the agile Renault Mégane RS to the legendary Volkswagen Golf GTI, since their prices and performances are more or less similar.
Space and Confort: both competitors are sporty hatchbacks that are quite a lunge away from their common versions. Whereas the Mégane RS is a variation of the 3-door Mégane Coupé, the Golf GTI can also have a 5-door configuration; this gives the latter an advantage in interior space, since the Renault's back seats and boot space are rather limited when compared to its opponent. The rear visibility of the Volkswagen is also better, due to the Mégane's sleek lines. The build quality of the Golf matches that of the Renault, but while some plastics in the latter may look cheap, the interior looks is light-years away from the outdated tablier of the Volkswagen.
Ride and Performance: the 2.0 gasoline engines produce a healthy dose of power for their size: 250 in the RS and 210 in the GTI, both delivering a beautiful engine note (they're not Maseratis, but still...). And here's where the Volkswagen starts swallowing its pride: it can do around 6.9 seconds from 0 to 100 km/h and attain a reasonable top speed of 240 km/h. Sounds good to you? To the Mégane, it doesn't. This french warrior can reach 100 km/h in a mere 6.1 seconds and fight to a maximum of 250 km/h. "So what's the big difference?" you ask. I'll tell you what's the big difference: when you thought the mythical GTI would outrun its opponent by speeding through every corner like a rolling thunder, you were wrong. Once again, the Renault is better - it feels better when cornering than its german pal.
And it's not over yet.
Economy and Pricing: this is where the Mégane ends its finishing blow. You can afford the RS from around 37.800 € (portuguese price. You may pay a lot less since our country is deep in debts), but the GTI's price starts around 41 K - for the 3-door version. Plus, both cars spend similar quantities of fuel in the same distance (8.2 l/100 km - 28.7 mpg for the Mégane and 7.3 l/100 km - 32.2 mpg for the Golf.)
Master's Choice: GTI fans, I'm sorry to announce your favorite hot hatchback has failed in a battle against the mighty Mégane RS. You might argue that there is still the R version... which costs around 15 K more than its french opponent. With that amount of cash, you could turn the RS into a wannabe racing machine - modifying the electronic central unit (ECU) costs less than 1000 euros, so think what 15 times that money would do to your 250 cv ride...
Renault Mégane RS: 15/20
Volkswagen Golf GTI: 14/20